When everything looks good, what makes a brand stand out?

As creativity becomes easier to produce, being distinctive may become one of the hardest things to achieve.

 

I've been noticing something lately. More and more brands look remarkably good.

Beautiful imagery, polished films, sophisticated typography, carefully composed social content. The overall standard of marketing production has improved enormously, and AI is making many of these capabilities accessible to almost everyone.

I find that genuinely exciting. Smaller brands can now create things that would previously have required substantial budgets, specialist teams and weeks of production.

But there's a paradox.

The easier it becomes to make something look good, the less valuable looking good becomes on its own.

And I wonder whether we're spending enough time thinking about what that means for brand building. Because professional-looking communication isn't necessarily distinctive communication. And distinctive communication isn't necessarily communication that people will remember as yours.

“The easier it becomes to make something look good, the less valuable looking good becomes on its own.”

The difference between looking good and being remembered

Think about the last few advertisements you saw. You might remember a beautiful film, a clever line or a particularly striking visual. But could you remember which brand it belonged to? That's a more difficult question. In marketing, we often talk about standing out. But standing out and being recognised are two different challenges. A campaign can attract attention without building a lasting connection to the brand behind it. This is where the research into distinctive brand assets, particularly the work associated with the Ehrenberg-Bass Institute, becomes important. Colours, characters, shapes, sounds, typography and other recognisable elements can help people identify a brand without needing to read its name. But these assets don't become distinctive simply because a designer creates them. They become distinctive through consistent use and repeated association with the brand. And that's what makes them valuable. A distinctive identity isn't just a visual system. It's an investment in memory.

“Attention is valuable. But attention that doesn’t connect back to the brand may be creating more value for the content than for the advertiser.”

The engagement illusion

One finding in WARC's The Marketer's Toolkit 2027 caught my attention. The report references research from System1, WPP Media and TikTok indicating that engagement rate had no relationship with brand memory in the study examined.

Instead, creative quality, the creator's familiarity among the target audience and the fit between creator and brand were more closely associated with building memory structures. It's a finding from a particular research setting, not a universal conclusion that engagement never matters. But it challenges an assumption that has become deeply embedded in digital marketing. We often treat engagement as evidence that communication is working. A video gets thousands of likes. A post generates comments. A creator delivers impressive reach. And we celebrate. But what exactly have we achieved?

  • Did people remember the brand?

  • Did they connect the message to the right company?

  • Did the communication strengthen an association that might influence a future purchase?

  • Or did we simply create something people enjoyed for a few seconds?

I think these questions deserve much more attention, particularly as brands invest in larger volumes of short-form content and creator collaborations.

Attention is valuable. But attention that doesn't connect back to the brand may be creating more value for the content than for the advertiser.

 

When personalisation starts to dilute personality

AI offers extraordinary opportunities to adapt creative work. We can generate variations for different audiences, markets, channels and contexts with a speed that would have been difficult to imagine only a few years ago. That's useful. Relevance matters, and different audiences don't always respond to the same message. But I see a potential risk.What happens when every audience receives a slightly different version of the brand? Different visuals. Different language. Different emotional cues. Different creative executions, all optimised for their immediate context. Individually, each variation may perform well. Collectively, they may begin to weaken the very thing that makes the brand recognisable.

This isn't an argument against personalisation. It's an argument for knowing what should remain consistent. A strong brand needs room to adapt without losing its identity. That requires more than a set of brand guidelines. It requires a clear understanding of which elements carry the brand's identity, which associations we're trying to build and which creative decisions should remain consistent even when performance data suggests another variation might deliver a few more clicks.

The goal shouldn't be to make every execution look the same. It should be to make different executions feel unmistakably connected.

 

Creativity still needs a point of view

Another interesting tension appears in Smartly's The Agentic Era: A Marketer's Guide. The report, based on research involving 500 marketers, distinguishes between tasks that benefit from automation and activities where human strategic leadership remains particularly important.

Strategic positioning and core brand storytelling sit in the latter category, while production scaling, variations and operational tasks offer greater opportunities for automation. It's a useful framework, although it reflects the report's research and recommendations rather than a definitive division of what humans and AI can do. What interests me is the distinction between producing creative work and deciding what the creative work should achieve. AI can help us explore directions, develop executions and test alternatives. But before any of that, someone needs to decide what the brand should stand for.

  • What do we want people to associate with us?

  • What should feel different about our communication?

  • Which conventions in our category are worth challenging?

  • And perhaps most importantly, what are we prepared to commit to over time?

Because distinctiveness requires choices.

It means deciding that some things are more important than others, and resisting the temptation to reinvent the brand every time a new visual trend appears. That's not always easy in a culture that rewards novelty. But I suspect consistency will become an increasingly valuable creative discipline.

 

What I'd do differently

If I were reviewing a brand identity or creative strategy today, I'd look beyond whether the work feels contemporary and professionally executed. I'd want to understand whether we're building something recognisable.

First, test recognition without the logo.

Show customers or relevant audiences selected campaign assets without the brand name. Can they identify the company? And if they can't, which brand do they think the communication belongs to? The answers can be uncomfortable, but they're useful. They reveal whether the creative work is strengthening your identity or simply following the visual conventions of the category.

Second, identify what deserves to remain consistent.

Not every colour, layout or piece of content needs to be identical. But a brand should know which distinctive elements it wants to build familiarity around. Those elements need enough exposure and consistency to become associated with the brand.

Third, evaluate creative effectiveness beyond engagement.

I'd want to understand not only whether people noticed or enjoyed the communication, but whether they remembered who it came from. That means considering brand attribution, recognition and relevant associations alongside reach, engagement and conversion. And I'd make sure those insights influence the next creative brief.

“The future won’t belong to the brands that can create the most beautiful content. It will belong to those that make their creativity unmistakably their own.”

The opportunity isn't to produce more creativity. It's to build more value from it.

I don't think AI will make creativity less important. Quite the opposite. As production becomes faster and more accessible, the value of good creative judgement may increase. The ability to recognise an interesting cultural shift. To understand what people care about. To develop an idea that feels relevant and surprising. And to connect that idea to a brand in a way that strengthens its identity. Those are the capabilities I believe will matter. Because when everyone has access to increasingly sophisticated creative tools, the competitive advantage is unlikely to come from the tools themselves. It will come from the decisions behind the work.

What we choose to say. How we choose to express it. What we consistently reinforce. And what we're brave enough not to follow.

The future won't belong to the brands that can create the most beautiful content. It will belong to those that make their creativity unmistakably their own.

And that's a challenge I find genuinely exciting.

 

Sources & further reading

WARC (2026) — The Marketer's Toolkit 2027, Chapter 2, p. 17. Discusses creator partnerships, creative effectiveness and research by System1, WPP Media and TikTok on engagement and brand memory.

Smartly (September 2026) — The Agentic Era: A Marketer's Guide, p. 4. Research-based framework distinguishing high-strategic-value brand activities from tasks suited to greater automation.

Ehrenberg-Bass Institute for Marketing Science — Research on distinctive brand assets, brand recognition and the role of consistent brand cues in building mental availability.


Previous
Previous

The value of feeling something

Next
Next

The dangerous comfort of being recommended