As AI changes how people discover brands, being recommended and being genuinely wanted are becoming two very different things.
I've been thinking quite a lot about what happens to brands when AI becomes a natural part of how we discover products, compare alternatives and make decisions. It's a fascinating development, and one that opens up enormous possibilities for both businesses and consumers. But there's a question I keep coming back to: what happens to the value of a brand when someone else increasingly decides which options we get to see?
For years, marketers have worked to make brands visible at the right moment, in the right place and to the right audience. Now, AI-powered assistants are beginning to influence those moments in a different way. Instead of browsing through search results, consumers can ask a question and receive a carefully presented selection of recommendations.
It's convenient, efficient and often genuinely helpful. But I wonder whether we're at risk of confusing two very different achievements: being recommended by an AI system and being a brand that people actively want to choose.
Being recommended isn't the same as being preferred
Imagine you're looking for a new pair of running shoes. You ask an AI assistant for recommendations, explain your needs and receive a shortlist of suitable options. One of the brands is unfamiliar, but the description sounds convincing, the reviews are positive and the product appears to offer good value.
You might consider buying it. But would you feel the same confidence choosing it over a brand you've known, seen and perhaps admired for years?
That difference interests me because it goes to the heart of what brand building has always been about. A strong brand is more than a collection of product attributes or a convincing description. It's an accumulation of experiences, associations, expectations and trust that develops over time.
AI can help people identify relevant alternatives, but being included in a recommendation doesn't automatically create the familiarity or confidence that makes someone comfortable choosing a particular brand.
And recent research suggests that consumers are making that distinction themselves.
87%
of respondents said they don't completely trust AI tools and verify information using other sources.
In Brand Building in the AI Age (2026), research by The Trade Desk Intelligence and PA Consulting, involving 3,000 consumers in the US and UK, found that 87% of respondents said they don't completely trust AI tools and verify information using other sources.
I find that particularly interesting. It suggests that while AI may make discovery faster, consumers still look beyond the initial answer when they want reassurance. The study doesn't tell us that every purchase follows this pattern, but it offers a useful reminder that appearing in a recommendation and earning someone's trust are not necessarily the same moment.
What does AI actually know about your brand?
There's another dimension to this that I think deserves attention. AI recommendations don't exist independently of the world around them. They're influenced by the information, associations and signals available about a brand across different sources.
WARC's The Marketer's Toolkit 2027 highlights the relationship between existing brand equity and visibility in AI-generated recommendations. It references an analysis suggesting that a substantial proportion of a brand's visibility in large language models can be associated with the brand equity it has already established.
The precise relationship will vary between brands, categories and AI systems, but the strategic implication is interesting. The work companies have invested in over many years may influence how they are represented in entirely new discovery environments.
This makes me question the idea that brands should suddenly redirect all their attention towards optimising for AI recommendations.
Of course, businesses need to make their information accessible, accurate and easy for AI systems to understand. But I would be cautious about treating visibility in AI-generated answers as a replacement for building a strong brand in people's minds.
If anything, the two need to work together.
Building a brand before someone needs it
One of the things I find most valuable about brand building is that its influence often begins long before someone is ready to buy.
We notice brands through advertising, conversations, experiences, culture and the people around us. Over time, these encounters create familiarity and expectations. Some brands become associated with reliability, others with innovation, enjoyment or a particular way of seeing the world.
We don't always consciously remember where those impressions came from, but they can influence how we respond when a brand eventually appears among our options.
That accumulated familiarity matters because purchasing decisions aren't made through information alone. Even when people compare products rationally, they bring expectations and previous impressions into the process.
For marketers, this creates an interesting challenge. We need to think about how brands are represented in AI-generated answers, while continuing to invest in the experiences and communication that make those brands meaningful to people in the first place.
It's not necessarily a choice between brand building and AI visibility. The opportunity lies in understanding how they support each other.
“Being recommended is valuable. Being genuinely wanted is something worth building a brand for.”
The opportunity beyond the recommendation
If I were reviewing a brand strategy today, I'd want to understand both how easily the brand can be discovered and why someone would choose it once they find it.
Is the brand clearly positioned? Does it have a recognisable identity and a meaningful role in customers' lives? Are its claims supported by credible information and real experiences? And does its communication create something beyond immediate product consideration?
I'd also want to understand how customers move between AI tools, search engines, social platforms, reviews and the brand's own channels. The journey may be changing, but people still need reasons to feel confident about their decisions.
I think there's a real opportunity here for brands that approach AI with curiosity rather than anxiety. Better discovery tools can help people find relevant products and services, including brands they might otherwise have overlooked. That's a positive development.
But it also makes the distinction between visibility and preference worth protecting.
Because ultimately, I don't believe the most valuable position for a brand is simply to be included in an AI-generated shortlist. It's to have built enough relevance, familiarity and trust that when people encounter it, they already have a reason to care.
Being recommended is valuable. Being genuinely wanted is something worth building a brand for.
Sources & further reading
The Trade Desk Intelligence & PA Consulting (2026) — Brand Building in the AI Age, pp. 3–4, 8–9. Consumer research involving 3,000 respondents in the US and UK, supplemented by consumer journey mapping and expert interviews.
WARC (2026) — The Marketer's Toolkit 2027, Chapter 1. Analysis of AI-driven discovery, brand equity and the relationship between existing brand strength and AI visibility.