We're getting remarkably good at optimising marketing. But are we getting better at growing businesses?
I have a complicated relationship with marketing dashboards. I love the clarity they bring and the opportunity to make smarter decisions based on real data. But I've also seen how easy it is to become so focused on improving the numbers in front of us that we forget to question whether we're measuring the right things.
With AI accelerating everything from media buying to creative production, the opportunities to improve efficiency are enormous. Yet I keep coming back to one question: are we becoming better at creating business value, or simply better at optimising the activities we can measure?
When good marketing numbers hide poor business results
Imagine a company whose digital marketing performance has improved significantly. Cost per click is down, conversion rates are up and campaigns generate more leads for the same budget. On paper, everything looks promising. But profitability hasn't improved. The sales team spends more time qualifying leads, customers are increasingly price-sensitive and the additional revenue isn't translating into stronger margins.
It's a hypothetical example, but it illustrates a familiar challenge. A campaign can perform exceptionally well against its objectives without necessarily creating equivalent value for the business.
We measure the cost of acquiring leads without always understanding their commercial potential. We celebrate conversions without considering customer quality, contribution margin or the resources required to turn an enquiry into a profitable relationship.
Performance metrics are essential, but they should help us understand business performance, not become the definition of success.
“Performance metrics are essential, but they should help us understand business performance, not become the definition of success.”
When optimisation becomes the strategy
In Smartly's The Agentic Era: A Marketer's Guide (2026), research involving 500 marketers shows how extensively AI is already being applied to marketing operations. Roughly half of the workflows examined were being optimised with AI, from creative development to project management and operational processes.
The potential is exciting, particularly for businesses with limited resources. We can test more ideas, reduce unnecessary production costs and free up time for work that creates greater value.
But there's a difference between making marketing operations more efficient and making marketing more effective.
An algorithm can become exceptionally good at achieving a defined objective. If we ask it to generate the cheapest possible leads, it will optimise towards that goal. But unless we've connected the objective to customer quality and profitability, we may simply become better at attracting the wrong customers.
The risk isn't automation itself. It's becoming extraordinarily efficient at pursuing objectives that were never sufficiently connected to the business strategy.
When less traffic might mean more value
There's another interesting dimension to this as AI changes how people search for information.
In Brand Building in the AI Age (2026), The Trade Desk Intelligence and PA Consulting explore how AI-generated answers may reduce visits to websites that primarily provide simple information. The report also cites McKinsey's forecast that traditional search volume could decline by 20–50% by 2028.
The report suggests that as more basic questions are answered directly by AI, some of the traffic that remains on the open internet may represent people with stronger intentions to explore, evaluate or purchase.
I find that an interesting possibility, particularly for businesses that have traditionally measured digital success through growing website traffic.
A decline in visits might look worrying in a dashboard, but if the people who do arrive are more relevant, more engaged and more likely to become valuable customers, the commercial picture could be quite different.
It doesn't mean traffic volume no longer matters, or that every visitor arriving from AI-influenced search is more valuable. But it does suggest that understanding why people visit, what they're looking for and what happens afterwards may become more important than simply counting how many arrive.
The hidden economics of marketing
Consider two campaigns. One generates 200 leads at €20 each, while another generates 100 leads at €35 each. The first appears more efficient, but what if the second attracts customers with higher purchase values, stronger margins and a greater likelihood of returning?
Suddenly, the comparison becomes much more interesting.
This is why I believe marketing needs a closer relationship with the financial side of the business. Customer acquisition cost becomes far more meaningful when connected to contribution margin, customer lifetime value and the actual cost of serving different customer groups.
We don't need to turn every marketing decision into a financial modelling exercise. But we do need to understand what a valuable customer looks like, rather than assuming that more customers automatically means better business.
Better questions lead to better investments
If I were reviewing a company's marketing strategy today, I'd start with commercial priorities rather than channel performance. Does the business need more customers, stronger margins, greater purchase frequency or a more profitable customer mix? Different objectives require different marketing decisions.
I'd also want marketing, sales and finance to share a clearer definition of success. When these functions evaluate performance from different perspectives, it's easy to optimise one part of the business at the expense of another.
And I'd look carefully at what we're doing with the efficiency gains technology creates. Are we using the time and resources we save to improve strategic thinking, develop stronger creative ideas and create better customer experiences? Or are we simply filling the available capacity with more activity?
Efficiency should create room for better decisions, not just more output.
“The goal isn’t to make marketing look better on a dashboard. It’s to make the business perform better because of it.”
The real opportunity is to become more effective
I'm genuinely optimistic about what technology can do for marketing. Automation, better targeting and faster testing create opportunities that were previously available mainly to organisations with substantial resources.
But I don't think the greatest advantage will belong to the companies that automate the most or achieve the lowest cost per click. It will belong to those that understand where marketing creates value and use technology to strengthen that contribution.
That requires commercial understanding, strategic judgement and the confidence to challenge impressive-looking numbers when they don't translate into meaningful business results.
The goal isn't to make marketing look better on a dashboard. It's to make the business perform better because of it.
Sources & further reading
The Trade Desk Intelligence & PA Consulting (2026) — Brand Building in the AI Age, pp. 5–6. Research on AI-driven search behaviour, consumer intent and the changing value of digital traffic. The report cites McKinsey's forecast of declining traditional search volume.
McKinsey (October 2025) — New front door to the internet: Winning in the age of AI search. Forecasts and analysis of how AI search may affect traditional search behaviour.
Smartly (September 2026) — The Agentic Era: A Marketer's Guide, p. 12. Research involving 500 marketers on AI adoption and workflow optimisation.