The value of feeling something

Technology can make almost anything easier to compare. But can it make us care?

 

We can analyse more, produce faster and personalise almost endlessly. Technology is giving us extraordinary possibilities, but I keep coming back to something rather fundamental: great marketing has never been just about delivering the right information. It's about making people feel something.

The craft of understanding human behaviour, finding a meaningful insight and turning it into an idea that genuinely connects with people hasn't become less important. If anything, I believe it's becoming more valuable. When products, prices and features can be compared in seconds, the real challenge isn't simply proving that your brand is a good choice. It's creating a reason for someone to actually want it. And that takes curiosity, empathy, strategic thinking and creative judgement.

 

The difference between a good choice and the right choice

We like to think we're rational consumers. We compare prices, read specifications and look for evidence that we're making sensible decisions. Yet anyone who has worked with brands knows that the reasons people give for choosing something don't always tell the whole story.

Consider two hotels with similar locations, prices and guest ratings. On paper, they're almost interchangeable. Yet one feels like somewhere you'd genuinely love to stay, while the other simply meets your requirements. Perhaps it's the atmosphere, the design or a story you've heard about the place. Somehow, you can imagine yourself there before you've even made the booking.

That feeling isn't necessarily irrational. It reflects experiences, expectations and personal associations that matter to us, even if they don't fit neatly into a comparison table. The hotel hasn't simply communicated what it offers. It has created a sense of what the experience might mean. And as technology takes more of the effort out of comparing alternatives, I believe this distinction becomes increasingly important.

 

When everything can be compared, what creates preference?

AI-powered shopping and recommendation systems are making it easier to evaluate products and services. For consumers, that's a real advantage. For brands, it raises an interesting challenge.

If your competitive advantage is that your product is faster, cheaper or offers a particular feature, technology makes that advantage easier to communicate. But it also makes it easier for customers to discover when a competitor offers something similar. Functional superiority still matters enormously, and in many categories it's decisive. But when several products meet the same practical requirements, what makes someone prefer one over another?

This is where emotional relevance becomes particularly valuable. Not because people stop caring about performance or price, but because brands need to create value beyond the attributes that can be compared. And that value rarely comes from simply telling people how wonderful a product is. It comes from understanding what matters to them and finding a meaningful connection between those needs and the brand.

 

Can technology manufacture emotion?

There's an interesting tension in WARC's The Marketer's Toolkit 2027. The report examines consumer reactions to AI-generated advertising and references research suggesting that people may be more accepting of AI-created communication when its purpose is functional. Emotional advertising produced with AI, however, can provoke more negative reactions in certain circumstances.

The findings vary between studies and categories, and WARC is careful to point out that consumer acceptance is still evolving. What feels appropriate for a technology product may be very different from what people expect of a luxury brand built around craftsmanship and human care.

I don't think the conclusion is that AI shouldn't be used to create emotional advertising. That would be far too simplistic. What interests me is what this tells us about authenticity. As we become capable of generating increasingly sophisticated images, films and stories, we also need to ask whether the emotion we're creating feels connected to something genuine.

A beautiful film can move people regardless of how it was produced. But if the emotional story has little relevance to the brand, it risks becoming entertainment rather than effective communication. And that's not a new problem created by AI. It's a challenge we've always faced in advertising: emotion without relevance is just decoration.

 

The craft behind making people care

I think we sometimes make emotional marketing sound easier than it is. We talk about storytelling, authenticity and creating connections as though adding a touching film or an inspiring message automatically makes a brand meaningful. But the real work happens long before the creative execution.

It starts with understanding people: their motivations, frustrations, aspirations and the cultural context in which they make decisions. Then comes the strategic judgement of finding the connection between what matters to the audience and what the brand can credibly contribute.

Sometimes the answer is humour, sometimes reassurance, excitement, pride or belonging. Emotional communication doesn't have to be sentimental, and it certainly doesn't require every brand to invent a grand purpose. A food brand might become associated with the pleasure of sharing something ordinary. A technology company might build confidence by making a complicated experience feel manageable. A service provider might create emotional value simply by making customers feel understood.

These connections work because they're relevant, not because they're emotional for the sake of it. This is where I believe human insight and creative craftsmanship remain essential. Technology can help us explore ideas, develop executions and adapt communication, but it doesn't remove the need to understand what makes an idea meaningful in the first place.

 

Feeling something should also mean something for the business

Creating emotional connections isn't just a creative ambition. It needs to contribute to commercial performance.

Les Binet and Peter Field's research into advertising effectiveness has long demonstrated the importance of balancing long-term brand building with shorter-term sales activation. Emotional communication can help build lasting associations and future demand, while activation helps turn existing demand into action. The balance differs between categories and businesses, but the principle is important: brands need to create demand, not simply capture it.

When people recognise, trust and feel positively towards a brand, that can influence how readily they consider it, how much persuasion they need and whether they return. It doesn't mean emotional advertising automatically creates growth or pricing power. Product quality, availability, customer experience and competitive conditions still matter. But it does mean that emotional relevance deserves to be treated as a commercial investment, not just a creative preference.

If I were reviewing a brand's communication strategy today, I'd want to understand not only whether a campaign generates attention or immediate response, but what it leaves behind. What do people remember? What associations are we strengthening? Are we creating a reason to choose the brand that extends beyond the individual campaign? And how will those associations contribute to the business over time?

 

The opportunity to be more human

What excites me about the next phase of marketing is that technology can take some of the complexity out of how we research, create and communicate. That gives us more possibilities, greater efficiency and potentially more room to focus on the work that really matters.

But I don't believe it changes the fundamentals of great marketing. We still need to understand people, recognise what matters to them and turn those insights into ideas that connect. We still need the courage to make creative choices, the judgement to know what feels right and the discipline to connect creativity to business results.

The tools will continue to evolve. The craft needs to evolve with them, but it shouldn't get lost along the way. Making a brand easier to find, understand or compare is one thing. Making people genuinely care about it is something else.

And perhaps that's where the greatest opportunity lies: using everything technology makes possible to become even better at what great marketing has always been about. Moving people.

 

Sources & further reading

WARC (2026) — The Marketer's Toolkit 2027, Chapter 5: The AI Tightrope, particularly p. 43. Research and analysis on consumer acceptance of AI-generated advertising, emotional communication and the role of human creative judgement.

Les Binet & Peter Field (2013) — The Long and the Short of It, IPA. Research into the complementary roles of long-term brand building and short-term sales activation.

Les Binet & Peter Field (2018) — Effectiveness in Context, IPA. Further research into how advertising effectiveness and the balance between brand building and activation vary across business contexts.


Previous
Previous

The efficiency trap: When better metrics lead to worse decisions

Next
Next

When everything looks good, what makes a brand stand out?